You are here:About>Entertainment>Alternative Music> Alt/Indie 101> Top Ten Best Albums of 2006 Lists -- A Meta-List of the Best Albums of 2006
About.comAlternative Music

Top 10 Best Alt/Indie Albums of 2006 Lists

From Joey Rubin,
Your Guide to Alternative Music.
FREE Newsletter. Sign Up Now!

The end of the year can be a time for reflection, but in the world of music journalism, it can also be a time of confusion -- every single paper, magazine, website and blog tries to tell you which were the Best Albums Of, and mostly they disagree. For those who, in 2006, want to avoid list-reading and opinion cross-checking, below are the Top Ten Best Album of 2006 lists of 2006 -- culled from the many sources I read, the few reviewers I trust, and including what, frankly, I think are the Best Albums of 2006. So, if you only read ten Best Album Of 2006 lists this year, read these ten. They're the best.

1. Metacritic's Best Reviewed Albums of 2006

Metacritic grades albums numerically based on how reviewers in other publications critique each release. So their Best Albums list is really a collection of which albums received the highest aggregated score. Their top alt/indie albums, in reverse order:

  • Ys - Joanna Newsom
  • Return To Cookie Mountain - TV On The Radio
  • Destroyer's Rubies - Destroyer
  • Boys And Girls In America - The Hold Steady
  • The Drift - Scott Walker
  • The Crane Wife - The Decemberists
  • I Am Not Afraid Of You And I Will Beat Your... - Yo La Tengo
  • Fox Confessor Brings The Flood - Neko Case
  • Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not - Arctic Monkeys

2. Insound's Best Selling Albums of 2006

Insound.com was among the first independent record sellers to head online, and those that know indie rock shop at Insound. Thus, there must be significance to their top sellers of the year. They were:

  • 10 Gulag Orkestar - Beirut
  • 9 The Greatest - Cat Power
  • 8 Oh No! Oh My! - Oh No! Oh My!
  • 7 The Best Party Ever - The Boy Least Likely To
  • 6 Clap Your Hands Say Yeah - Clap Your Hands Say Yeah
  • 5 Everything All The Time - Band Of Horses
  • 4 Return To Cookie Mountain - TV on the Radio
  • 3 Wowee Zowee: Sordid Sentinels - Pavement
  • 2 The Loon - Tapes 'n Tapes
  • 1 Nine Times That Same Song - Love Is All

3. The Onion A.V. Club's Best Music of 2006

America's finest news source is also a mighty fine source for good music. I trust their to-the-point opinions almost as much as I trust their sardonic satire (alt/indie picks only):

  • 13 And The Glass Handed Kites - Mew
  • 12 The Body The Blood The Machine - The Thermals
  • 10 Everything All The Time - Band Of Horses
  • 9 Fox Confessor Brings The Flood - Neko Case
  • 7 The Crane Wife - The Decemberists
  • 5 The Life Pursuit - Belle & Sebastian
  • 4 Rabbit Fur Coat - Jenny Lewis With The Watson Twins
  • 3 The Trials Of Van Occupanther - Midlake
  • 2 Return To Cookie Mountain - TV On The Radio
  • 1 Boys And Girls In America - The Hold Steady

4. NPR's All Songs Considered Best CDs of 2006

These days, NPR is a lot less stodgy than you might imagine. This listener-chosen top ten proves that NPR listeners have pretty good taste in tunes:

  • 10 Begin to Hope - Regina Spektor
  • 9 Orphans - Tom Waits
  • 8 Rabbit Fur Coat - Jenny Lewis and the Watson Twins
  • 7 The Greatest - Cat Power
  • 6 Ys - Joanna Newsom
  • 5 Return to Cookie Mountain - TV On the Radio
  • 4 Post War - M. Ward
  • 3 Modern Times - Bob Dylan
  • 2 Fox Confessor Brings the Flood - Neko Case
  • 1 The Crane Wife - The Decemberists

5. The Guardian's "Definitive Top 10 Albums of the Year"

Assigning points to albums ranked in other Best Of lists, the Guardian attempted to mathematically figure what albums really are the best of 2006. As my only UK sample, this selection stands out as quite different from the bunch:

  • 10 Costello Music - The Fratellis & Cansei De Ser Sexy - CSS
  • 8 Broken Boy Soldiers - The Raconteurs
  • 7 Alright, Still - Lily Allen
  • 6 Burial - Burial
  • 5 Ys - Joanna Newsom & Black Holes And Revelations - Muse
  • 3 Modern Times - Bob Dylan
  • 2 Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not - Arctic Monkeys
  • 1 The Warning - Hot Chip

6. UCLA Radio's "10 Favorite 2006 Albums"

Supposedly, college kids know what's hip. So, for a bit of co-ed perspective, a list from the DJs at one of the bigger schools out West:

  • 10 Return to the Sea - Islands
  • 9 We, the Vehicles - Maritime
  • 8 St. Elsewhere - Gnarls Barkley
  • 7 The Life Pursuit - Belle & Sebastian
  • 6 Modern Times - Bob Dylan
  • 5 The Crane Wife - The Decemberists
  • 4 Fishscale - Ghostface Killah
  • 3 Everything All the Time - Band of Horses
  • 2 Ys - Joanna Newsom
  • 1 Return to Cookie Mountain - TV on the Radio

7. Nerd Report's Top Albums of 2006

A list of with some unexpected albums. Leave it to a Nerd to break the mold of Best Of predictability:

  • 10 Demon - Envelopes
  • 9 Rather Ripped - Sonic Youth
  • 8 Rocinate - Ester Drang
  • 7 Roots & Crowns - Califone
  • 6 Mr. Beast - Mogwai
  • 5 The World is Gone - Various
  • 4 Citrus - Asobi Seksu
  • 3 Garden Ruin - Calexico
  • 2 Offshore - Early Day Miners
  • 1 II - Espers

8. Marathonpacks' Top Albums of 2006

Over at Marathonpacks, "longevity is key." Or, in other words, the list is “selected and ranked in order of how much I listened to and enjoyed each one this year.” Is that different from most Best Of criteria? Only alt/indie albums included:

  • 14 ‘Sno Angel Like You - Howe Gelb
  • 13 Citrus - Asobi Seksu
  • 12 Fab Four Suture - Stereolab
  • 9 Cansei de Ser Sexy - CSS
  • 8 Fort Recovery - Centro-Matic
  • 6 Show Your Bones - Yeah Yeah Yeahs
  • 5 Ships - Danielson
  • 4 Silent Shout - The Knife
  • 3 Destroyer's Rubies - Destroyer
  • 2 The Life Pursuit - Belle & Sebastian

9. Jeremy Enigk's Top 10 of 2006 at Filter Magazine

Sunny Day Real Estate is one of my favorite bands of all time, so I couldn't resist including a top ten compiled by the band's enigmatic frontman, Jeremy Enigk. I don't know if his musical taste is impeccable -- but when he filters those influences into the songs he writes, well, let's just say it's better than good taste:

  • Alligator - The National
  • Ys - Joanna Newsom
  • Life In Slow Motion - David Gray
  • Aha Shake Heartbreak - Kings Of Leon
  • How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb - U2
  • Gentleman - The Afghan Whigs
  • Oh Mercy - Bob Dylan
  • Life's Rich Pageant - R.E.M.
  • Trouble - Ray LaMontagne
  • Plans - Death Cab For Cutie

10. Largehearted Boy's 2006 Favorite Albums

Largehearted Boy runs an excellent blog, and his nearly-comprehensive 2006 year-end music list meta-list was an invaluable help while putting this list together. So I thought it only fair to point out that he has good taste, too:

  • Citrus - Asobi Seksu
  • Let's Get Out of This Country - Camera Obscura
  • Wind-Up Canary - Casey Dienel
  • Destroyer's Rubies - Destroyer
  • Yellow House - Grizzly Bear
  • Ys - Joanna Newsom
  • The Animal Years - Josh Ritter
  • Get Lonely - The Mountain Goats
  • Begin to Hope - Regina Spektor
  • Serena-Maneesh - Serena-Maneesh
  • Palo Santo - Shearwater

Want to buy the best of the best?

To check out prices on the best of the best, follow these links:

  • Joanna Newsom: Compare Prices
  • Asobi Seksu: Compare Prices
  • Band of Horses: Compare Prices
  • The Decembrists: Compare Prices
  • TV on the Radio: Compare Prices
Newsletters & RSSEmail to a friendSubmit to Digg
 All Topics | Email Article | | |
Advertising Info | News & Events | Work at About | SiteMap | Reprints | HelpOur Story | Be a Guide
User Agreement | Ethics Policy | Patent Info. | Privacy Policy©2008 About, Inc., A part of The New York Times Company. All rights reserved.